Exclusives

Error Coin Essentials: Collar Failure

Published November 17, 2026 | Read time 5 min read

By Mike Diamond

Save for Later
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

This article is sponsored by CAC Grading, the collectors’ choice, inspiring confidence through accurate and consistent coin grading.

Error Coin Essentials introduces the core concepts behind coins that didn’t come out quite right. These articles provide a practical foundation for collectors who want to understand how errors happen, how to identify them, and how to collect them. With strong collector demand and a wide variety of examples, error coins remain one of the hobby’s most engaging fields. 


The collar is a retaining ring that establishes the final diameter of a newly struck coin. Harder than the obverse and reverse dies, the collar should last through many die changes. As with any piece of hardened metal, the collar is subject to brittle failure. That failure can occur spontaneously or as the result of an impact.

Brittle collar failure can take many forms, some dramatic and some minor. The broad term “collar break” (aka “collar cud”) is used indiscriminately for these errors, obscuring their diverse manifestations.

Types of Collar Failure

The obverse of a 1985-P nickel with a bulge visible in the upper left edge.
The outline of this 1985-P nickel has a bulge from a full collar break. (Photo: Mike Diamond)
A side view of the 1985-P nickel with two vertical cracks showing the collar failure.
The edge of the nickel shows evidence of the collar break. (Photo: Mike Diamond)

The most iconic form of collar break entails the loss of a segment that can range anywhere from a few arc degrees to over 180 arc degrees. In plain collars, the missing segment may be confined to a tungsten carbide lining. Shown above is a 1985-P nickel with a “full collar break” that extends from 10:30 to 12 o’clock. During the strike, coin metal flowed into the gap left by the missing segment, creating a bulge in the coin’s circular outline.

A 1989-P nickel with a prominent bulge from the left side of the coin to the top right.
The irregular collar break on this 1989-P nickel is obvious from the front. (Photo: Mike Diamond)
The side view of the nickel, with a large crack running horizontally along the center
In this 1989-P 5-cent coin, the upper margin of the collar’s working face chipped off, resulting in an irregular collar break. The obverse die’s slight misalignment may be related to the collar break. (Photo: Mike Diamond)

Sometimes the upper portion of the collar’s working face breaks off, leaving the affected segment with a ragged upper margin. Termed “irregular collar breaks” or “marginal collar breaks,” these seem to be more common than full collar breaks. Shown above is a 1989-P nickel with an irregular collar break that extends from 9:15 to 1 o’clock. Many examples of this particular collar break exist. The obverse die shows a slight misalignment toward 5 o’clock. It’s possible that the obverse die was originally misaligned toward 11 o’clock and smacked into the collar, breaking some of it off. The collision might well have nudged the collar toward the opposite pole—this happens rather frequently. The obverse die stayed in this misaligned position while it struck many subsequent planchets.

An irregular collar break whose vertical extent exceeds the thickness of a planchet would be indistinguishable from a full collar break.

Small breaks along the upper margin of the collar are known as “collar chips.” This term also applies to reeded collars that lose a single vertical ridge.

The obverse of a 1965 nickel with a bulge running along the right side of the coin
A retained collar break encompassing 120 arc degrees appears on this 1965 5-cent coin.  The affected portion of the collar sank in or splayed outward.  No metal disappeared from the collar’s working face. (Photo: Mike Diamond)

A “retained collar break” occurs when a segment of the collar sinks into the surrounding softer metal or the segment splays laterally. Shown above is a 1965 5-cent coin with a retained collar break that extends from 12:15 to 4:30 o’clock. It’s clear that the entire collar is present, because evidence of collar contact appears on both sides of the two points of breakage.

Collar Cracks

The obverse of 1918 cent with a slightly distended bottom edge
Four vertical collar cracks allowed this 1918 cent to expand beyond normal parameters. (Photo: Mike Diamond)
The side view of the cent with a vertical crack down the center
One of the cracks discussed above is visible here. (Photo: Mike Diamond)

When a collar cracks, the line of fracture is almost always vertical. “Vertical collar cracks” can be isolated, appear in pairs (often at opposite poles), or develop at several locations. Shown above is one of four collar cracks that appear on the edge of a 1918 cent. The cracks are located at 1:30, 3:30, 7 o’clock, and 11 o’clock. The segments between the cracks spread out slightly, leaving the coin with an enlarged diameter (19.45 millimeters instead of the normal 19.05 millimeters).

Two wide cracks at opposite poles define a “bilateral split collar.” In such errors, the two sides of the collar spread apart, either permanently splayed or forced apart with each impact. This leaves the coin with an enlarged diameter along an axis perpendicular to the one that connects the two splits. Shown below is a 1964-D nickel with an impressive bilateral split collar.

This 1964-D 5-cent coin shows the results of a bilateral split collar.
This 1964-D 5-cent coin shows the results of a bilateral split collar. (Photo: Mike Diamond)

It can be difficult to distinguish bilateral split collars from retained collar breaks that encompass 180 arc degrees. The latter is generally characterized by a step-down at one break and a step-up at the other break. A bilateral split collar has raised nibs at each end.

Wear and plastic deformation can also affect collars, resulting in coins with blunt reeding, a widened diameter, and, in one case, a beveled edge.

As with brittle failure affecting the obverse and reverse die, one should be as specific as possible in describing the nature of any collar fracture.


Mike Diamond has been collecting, researching, and writing about error coins since 1997.  He previously wrote a weekly column for Coin World  (“Collectors’ Clearinghouse”) that focused on minting errors and die varieties.  Prior to that, he was responsible for dozens of articles that appeared in CONECA’s specialty journal Errorscope.  He created and contributed most of the content found in The Error-Variety Ready Reference.  Over the past 28 years, he has discovered or described well over 100 new error types.

Sign up for the monthly Reading Room Rundown to receive more great stories!